Dumb question

[Ugo26]

Hi all, last time, a friend came with his electro project he did with Logic.
Just the fact he imports his tracks and the HD was at 87/96 voices !

Don't you think there is a probleme with this HD wich cost 8000 vs Logic costing 500 ? Or it's me who's dumb ass ?

....

[BradLyons]

I don't understand the issue here---or what the question is. However understand Logic is an application, Pro Tools HD is an entire solution---big difference.

[Ugo26]

Haha I'm sorry, I really understand that PT HD is an entire solution but when you pay 8000 Euros for it, you should hope you can have unlimited tracks.
My question is : what may be my answer to my friend who import his project and can only apply 10 plug ins ? Here, what's the advantage to buy a system wich cost 16x the price of his Logic, the one he can have all his tracks and 40 plugs ?

I don't want to be unpleasant, I really love pro tools but sometimes, I'm asking questions ....

[crizdee]

Originally Posted by Ugo26

Hi all, last time, a friend came with his electro project he did with Logic.
Just the fact he imports his tracks and the HD was at 87/96 voices !

Don't you think there is a probleme with this HD wich cost 8000 vs Logic costing 500 ? Or it's me who's dumb ass ?

....

Hi,

Are you comparing the 2 DAW's only by the amount of tracks you can run? and the quantity of plugins? Well yes that is quite a dump question

And Logic @ €500 what interface did you get for that?

Pro tools can have up to 192 audio tracks and unlimited midi tracks!! how many do you need?

Perhaps Garage band would have been the right DAW for you? it has many tracks and plugins and loops to use and everything, and it costs less than Logic

Chris

[FajitaTone]

don't feed the trolls.

[Ugo26]

I'm not trolling, you just don't answer my question.
Yes I'm comparing by the amount of tracks, I'm not in my right ?
I'm comparing prices betwen DAW without AD/DA, why are you talking about 192 ???

This is not trolling, it seems you just can't answer my question, I'm HD owner and it's sure I'm not ready to change my DAW because of Edit, Mix etc. But my question was, don't you think 8000 Euros for such a little tracks and plug is just excessive ?

[musicman691]

Ugo:
I have to ask - how many tracks were actually playing at any one time? A lot of people that work in other daws use a ton of tracks but rarely do they all play at the same time. It's because those types like to have every little nuance of a softsynth on it's own track which will bloat the track count.

And if you need to use more than 10 effects on a track, something somewhere really needs to be re-thought. Sheer numbers don't always tell the story and can be misleading when playing the specsmanship game.

[Barry Johns]

T r o l l

[Ugo26]

Stop accusing me trolling ....

Thx musicman, you're right but he is doing electro music so he takes natural sounds and distroy them with lot of plug. I think he is about 57 tracks on his Logic not counting stereo ones so, on PT HD, we have 87 voices used without plug.
I was hoping I was wrong but, after reading all this useless answers (excepting you musicman) I think it's really sad we don't have much voices available.

I was waiting for answers like it's because HD is a DAW who's doing this/this and this to your audio so he can't do better but it's something you can't have on any other DAW.
It seems I was wrong ...

[starburst]

Ugo26, as I have recently found, this forum is full of industry pros who use pro tools daily. They are a great crowd and full of knowledge and experience. However, it is clear that the hostility you get when raising the type of questions you have comes down the fact that many of these fine folks have given digidesign many thousands of their hard earned money and they feel pretty peed off that a kid can come along with a system a fraction of the cost that out performs theirs.

The trouble is there is this almost religious devotion to the divine pro tools because it is considered the industry standard.
Sure its a great bit of software. Probably worth $500 or so. As for hardware that's a different question.