Please Fix the midi Timing

[Sardi]

Originally Posted by WernerF

All Avid VI's are midi time stamped. This makes them sample accurate. Just try the same test with Ivory, B4 or any Arturia VI. Also, you might want to try and trigger Slate Trigger with midi and do the same test. That is even more wildly erratic.

So then the issue is not Pro Tools, but rather certain 3rd party VI's.

Thread title is misleading then.

[nedorama]

I'd say given the OP gave no info on his system and plugins and hasn't bothered coming back to this thread with specifics, this is flamebait, pure and simple.

[Rail Jon Rogut]

I tested using our Evil Drums SDX in Superior Drummer in PT11 and the samples are sample accurate. All JUCE based plugins should also be sample accurate, if they're not - then contact the developers for a fix.

Rail

[Southsidemusic]

Originally Posted by Rail Jon Rogut

I tested using our Evil Drums SDX in Superior Drummer in PT11 and the samples are sample accurate. All JUCE based plugins should also be sample accurate, if they're not - then contact the developers for a fix.

Rail

Hi Rail

Just wanna say Great sample libraries you guys have

We use them in our sample players and VI's all the time and we love them.

Secondly wanted to say thank you for helping us out here on the forum
Really good CS and beyond
Best Regards
Christopher

[RyanC]

Originally Posted by WernerF

All Avid VI's are midi time stamped. This makes them sample accurate. Just try the same test with Ivory, B4 or any Arturia VI. Also, you might want to try and trigger Slate Trigger with midi and do the same test. That is even more wildly erratic.

I tested Kontakt via vep and was able to get a perfect null on non-round robin SL's. Can you describe your methodology so we can try it?

Also what hardware?

[DAWgEAR]

The comments in this thread and a couple of others have resulted in me trying to perform some tests regarding MIDI timing.

I am not sure what to make of my results, but delay compensation appears to interact with whether MIDI clips are on instrument or MIDI tracks. Perhaps that is a misunderstanding on my part.

To the extent that it might be relevant to this discussion, you might wish to glance at another thread I started in the PT 10 forum.

http://duc.avid.com/showthread.php?t=342182