Eleven Rack Edit Window PT 11 WHEN???

[Darryl Ramm]

Originally Posted by musicman691

I know I've posted a similar thought in other older threads on this same subject but I'm thinking there's major problems with the code for the 11R window integrating it into PT 11 that Avid can't solve. I'm thinking they might just do it as a standalone aax plugin instead. But that still wouldn't fulfill the wishes of many for a true standalone editor.

Compared to rewriting the current Eleven Rack GUI RTAS code to AAX-64 I could not imagine how to stuff a button to invoke that plugin into the GUI is hard at all, and would be much less work than productizing and testing a separate AAX-64 runtime environment to deliver a stand alone GUI. Now while I would like a stand alone GUI I would not ever argue that you would do that because it is going to be simpler to develop--I just don't see Avid say ever doing that outside of their AAX environment. I suspect the real issue here is just what is left of Avid engineering headcount just does not include enough folks to work on this. The core Eleven/Eleven Rack guitar team followed Elvis out the building a while ago...

[musicman691]

Originally Posted by Darryl Ramm

Compared to rewriting the current Eleven Rack GUI RTAS code to AAX-64 I could not imagine how to stuff a button to invoke that plugin into the GUI is hard at all, and would be much less work than productizing and testing a separate AAX-64 runtime environment to deliver a stand alone GUI. Now while I would like a stand alone GUI I would not ever argue that you would do that because it is going to be simpler to develop--I just don't see Avid say ever doing that outside of their AAX environment. I suspect the real issue here is just what is left of Avid engineering headcount just does not include enough folks to work on this. The core Eleven/Eleven Rack guitar team followed Elvis out the building a while ago...

The 'button' to invoke the plugin is already there - it's just the code module to make sense of what the buttons says to do isn't there. Different eyes looking at the code might be able to find and fix problems with that code. Like I said there has to be some significant problems getting the 11R gui editor code working in PT11 considering the total rewrite of base code.

I wouldn't mind paying extra (although we shouldn't have to) for a standalone editor but really want to see it working inside PT as well.

[YYR123]

Originally Posted by musicman691

I wouldn't mind paying extra .

Crazy talk just plain crazy !!!

Now don't go saying stuff like that

[lspaulsp]

OK, I just got news it's on the way.
Look for it sometime around APRIL 1st.

[YYR123]

Originally Posted by lspaulsp

OK, I just got news it's on the way.
Look for it sometime around APRIL 1st.

Hahaha

[musicman691]

Originally Posted by musicman691

So is Christmas, death and taxes.

Originally Posted by YYR123

We will roll the dice and see which one comes first......any takers?

Originally Posted by Noiselab

Feeling particularly cynical here. My bet is on ALL THREE before 11R in PT11!

NL

Originally Posted by YYR123

So Christmas is the timeline !!! Let's see

Well we rolled past Christmas 2013 with the gift from Avid of PT 11.1 and no 11R window. So that leaves two choices and neither is pretty.

[YYR123]

Originally Posted by musicman691

Well we rolled past Christmas 2013 with the gift from Avid of PT 11.1 and no 11R window. So that leaves two choices and neither is pretty.

Maybe we should have said Christmas taxes and then death !!!

[DonaldR]

I find it so funny that you're asking for an 11R edit window when the front-end is so easy to use and the main reason I bought my 11R!!! I only use the edit window to save my patches to disk and that's all.
Anyway it's like saying that I will never buy a Ferrari because the audio system sounds like [bleep][bleep][bleep][bleep]...

[YYR123]

What are you talking about

I'm rocking 10.3.7 window and all......but it's just another one of the things I need before I consider moving on/up

[musicman691]

Originally Posted by DonaldR

I find it so funny that you're asking for an 11R edit window when the front-end is so easy to use and the main reason I bought my 11R!!! I only use the edit window to save my patches to disk and that's all.
Anyway it's like saying that I will never buy a Ferrari because the audio system sounds like [bleep][bleep][bleep][bleep]...

You think the 11R front panel is easy to use for editing or creating patches? I sure as hell don't. You have to scroll through so many different screens it's easy to lose where you are and what you're doing.