Everyone stop using ARA right now

[climber]

Originally Posted by midnightrambler

With all due respect, I don’t have time to beta test your software for you. I’ve got my own job to do, talent to please, deadlines to meet, etc. I will try and ascertain what has and hasn’t gone wrong at some point, but in all honesty you really should have guys your end making sure this stuff doesn’t flake out at the merest hint of some pretty standard clip editing.

Wow… That’s not very nice. How do you expect anyone to try to help you if you won’t even supply the basic details of your system and versions. 🤦🏻*♂️

[midnightrambler]

Originally Posted by climber

Wow… That’s not very nice. How do you expect anyone to try to help you if you won’t even supply the basic details of your system and versions. ����*♂️

Yes I was on a particularly short fuse yesterday, apologies to all.

I *have* been through all of this before though: I had a man from Avid try a bunch a stuff on my comp, I took the time to make a video demonstrating the issues, I sent them the Tools file for analysis etc - so it’s not like I haven’t already contributed a fair chunk of my time trying to help get to the bottom of this. I’d be happy to shrug my shoulders and say “it’s a one-off” if it weren’t for the fact that it’s happened again on a completely different system with a completely different Tools session.

[Rich Breen]

Originally Posted by Vadym

I hope you understand that such posts without at least some details of your workflow are counterproductive. Please give more details about what version of ProTools, in what PT the session was created, were the ARA clips in the clip groups, did the ARA data fly off as a result, and whether these ARA clips were in the clip list or on the tracks. Thank you!

Of course we all should only post with system info, thorough description of problem, and steps to repro, but you have to admit the rollout of Melodyne ARA has been quite rocky, with so many unpredictable/weird bugs, it's enough to test anyone's patience. I don't know what the beta team's doing, but this has surely not been well vetted prior to release - after what, 6 months? A year? - I'm still finding ARA bugs that will destroy hours/days of work. And yes, I do report cases to TS when I can clearly describe and reproduce (see my post from earlier today for one).

A clear technical description of how the ARA system works, how ARA data is stored and what affects it would help us to figure out what's going on with some of these data loss issues.

[Darryl Ramm]

^^^ yes. There is generally too many changes that are happening in Pro Tools that seem not so well announced and not well documented/explained. And too many changes that are breaking things. The changes in plugin caching over the last half year is another example. Lots of users are still unaware of them. And the changes, while sure seem to be a great direction, have caused folks problems.

I hope Avid product/engineering management is on top of this, the good intentions and efforts here are really being impacted by problems. None of this stuff just happens, it's a management and process issue.

[Ptbright]

Really hope ARA will be fixed with the next update.

[Rich Breen]

Originally Posted by Darryl Ramm

^^^ yes. There is generally too many changes that are happening in Pro Tools that seem not so well announced and not well documented/explained. And too many changes that are breaking things. The changes in plugin caching over the last half year is another example. Lots of users are still unaware of them. And the changes, while sure seem to be a great direction, have caused folks problems. ....

There was a time when Avid/Digidesign published 'white papers' with in depth technical info - for example the details of the math in the mix engine, and there was this excellent webcast about the video engine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6gxLZid2VR4

This kind of info is essential for professional users to understand the tools we use, and can be tremendously helpful in chasing down unexpected behavior - I haven't seen anything like this for years from Avid. And yes, it comes from Management, and the current management of the beta process seems pretty woeful.

[Skytouch]

Is there an easy way to disable all ARA functionality in Pro Tools? Melodyne Studio 5.4.1 for me is unusable. Clicking in the UI, scrolling, zooming gum up randomly for several seconds at a time. I have not registered the Pro Tools ARA version, but Melodyne "helpfully" enables the ARA feature because the full Melodyne Studio version is on my computer.

Both the ARA feature and the AAX plugin exhibit this behavior. But the Melodyne Studio 5.4.1 standalone app without Pro Tools is running fine here, so this apparently is an integration issue with Pro Tools.

My configuration: Mac Studio M2 Max, Sonoma 14.7.1, Pro Tools Ultimate 2024.10.1, Melodyne Studio 5.4.1.

Sky

[tope d]

Originally Posted by Skytouch

Is there an easy way to disable all ARA functionality in Pro Tools? Melodyne Studio 5.4.1 for me is unusable. Clicking in the UI, scrolling, zooming gum up randomly for several seconds at a time. I have not registered the Pro Tools ARA version, but Melodyne "helpfully" enables the ARA feature because the full Melodyne Studio version is on my computer.

Both the ARA feature and the AAX plugin exhibit this behavior. But the Melodyne Studio 5.4.1 standalone app without Pro Tools is running fine here, so this apparently is an integration issue with Pro Tools.

My configuration: Mac Studio M2 Max, Sonoma 14.7.1, Pro Tools Ultimate 2024.10.1, Melodyne Studio 5.4.1.

Sky

Hi There!

Can you PM me your registered iLok ID or Email? The Email linked with your DUC account is not connected with any Pro Tools licenses or account. I'd like to open a support case for you.
For now, please try disabling your autobackup or reinstall your melodyne as a possible workaround. I'll wait for your account info.

Thank you

[Skytouch]

Greetings tope, I tried PM'ing you but access is blocked. I may open a support case on my own. Thank you,

Sky

[Skytouch]

Originally Posted by albee1952

Meanwhile, Melodyne still works perfectly fine as a plugin. I use it that way for the vast majority of my needs and only use the ARA version for a quick fix, which I immediately commit

My tests show that neither ARA nor the AAX plugin are working correctly here. I can launch Melodyne Studio 5.4.1 standalone which runs fine. For my current production I am importing an instrumental mix into Melodyne and will record vocals there. Or I may try using Logic Pro for tracking, mix and master; the session is fairly basic so this will be a good test case.

Sky