Everyone stop using ARA right now

[mds1001]

I'm using the latest version of Melodyne Editor.

[huzzam]

What are folks' experiences with Melodyne ARA on PT 2023.9? I'm afraid to start using it again after getting severely burned by lost edits in previous versions.

[JKR]

+1

[huzzam]

Answering my own question... Melodyne ARA in 2023.9 still has this bug. I had done some ARA edits, saved & quit. When I reopened the session, the edits were reported as lost, and the ARA window complained about corrupted data that automatically been fixed.


~peter in athens

[kedavis]

Which edition of Melodyne are you using, Peter?

[huzzam]

Originally Posted by kedavis

Which edition of Melodyne are you using, Peter?

Melodyne Assistant, latest version, on Mac Ventura 13.6 & Pro Tools 2023.9.

[Vadym]

Originally Posted by huzzam

Answering my own question... Melodyne ARA in 2023.9 still has this bug. I had done some ARA edits, saved & quit. When I reopened the session, the edits were reported as lost, and the ARA window complained about corrupted data that automatically been fixed.

What was the workflow during this session? please give us as much as possible context of what actions resulted with the ARA Data corruption after the session reopening.
If you can repeat the same steps with the same result it would be the best option.

[Fidelis]

Originally Posted by Vadym

What was the workflow during this session? please give us as much as possible context of what actions resulted with the ARA Data corruption after the session reopening.
If you can repeat the same steps with the same result it would be the best option.

So, from this message it seems like AVID could not reproduce this yet? Or is it already assigned as a bug? I stoped using ARA mode because of this. It’s been so long and it’s a bummer that you can not solve this. I mean this is the worst bug in Pro tools since its release….

[SundayFunday]

I’ve been using Melodyne ARA edits for months without issue. I fixed some vocals using Melodyne ARA in a previous version, and left the ARA edits active for months. I updated to the latest version when it came out, checked them today, no issue.

I went ahead and rendered them and listened again, no issue.
____________________________

PRO TOOLS STUDIO 2023.9
Focusrite 8i6 1st Gen
Focusrite ISAOne Preamp
Apple M1 Mac Mini 2021
• Model Name: Mac mini
• Model Identifier: Macmini9,1
• Chip: Apple M1
• Total Number of Cores: 8 (4 performance and 4 efficiency)
• Memory: 16 GB

TRUE FALLACY
alternative music from Dallas TX by Ben Gorena
https://youtube.com/truefallacy

Sunday Funday
Music Production techniques, reviews, & covers
http://youtube.com/sundayfunday

[midnightrambler]

Oh brilliant, that must mean it's working just fine. Everybody back to work.