Quote:
Originally Posted by rjbee
I was about to buy a s/pdif to xls cable to go from my tonelab desktop multi effects unit to my Focusrite 2i2 audio interface, then to Pro Tools First. It occurred to me that it may not be any better than the phono to phono connection since the signal may be converted to analog at the 2i2, negating the advantage of the s/pdif digital audio cable. Am I correct?
|
What model Tonelab? I have no idea what you mean by "desktop", these were all floor units AFAIK. The base model blue one? Or the ST? Or the LE? Or? If its an ST then you can use it as the audio interface to your Mac, but it has no S/PDIF so not likely the one you are talking about.
To reinforce what Janne is saying, your 2i2 has no digital I/O. No S/PDIF (or any other kind of) digital inputs or outputs. So you would need to use an outboard converter to go between analog or digital so lose any practical advantage, so just go analog. I think the Tonelab and LE (non ST) only has S/PDIF out which might handicap you if you want to reamp through it digitally. If you want to use the S/PDIF output of the Tonelab you would want to upgrade your interface to one with S/PDIF input (preferably S/PDIF on optical/TOSLINK to match what I think the Tonelabs have).
There are amp and effects sims within most DAWs which likely surpass the quality of what is in the Tonelab. Unfortunately Pro Tools First does not include decent amp and effects sims, such a totally bad product management decision for a beginner DAW, and in First you can't add third party plugins, only Avid ones. The Eleven family amps sims are pretty good.. and available in the nice "Avid Complete Plugin Bundle"... but this is all a confusing mess and getting off track. Ask if you want more help understanding amp and effects plugin options you have. Or change to a different DAW (including Garageband (!)) most other DAWs all have a wide offering of third party plugins. And if you are playing around with stuff post-tracking it's likely easier to play with in the DAW. And may be you know and just love the Tonelab and it's best for you to keep using that. That's a personal and artistic choice, and there is no right or wrong.
It's not clear what you are doing, tracking guitar though the Tonelab, using it for effects only or amp sim as well, if you are wanting to reamp through it etc. If you want suggestions from folks it may help to describe what you are trying to achieve, both artistically and technically. The *one* thing that I think is less open to personal choice is the benefit of tracking a dry guitar signal along with the wet (e.g. processed output of the Tonelab). I'm not sure if your Tonelab provides a dry output or if you will need to separately split that off before the input.
Alright, back to trying to program Fractal footswitches...