Avid Pro Audio Community

Avid Pro Audio Community (https://duc.avid.com/index.php)
-   macOS (https://duc.avid.com/forumdisplay.php?f=92)
-   -   New "Mac Studio" from Apple (https://duc.avid.com/showthread.php?t=419195)

off the wall 03-08-2022 11:10 AM

New "Mac Studio" from Apple
 
The just announced Mac Studio computer looks killer. Essentially a Max Mini. M1 Ultra CPU (two M1 Max's) up to 128GB unified RAM. Performance better than the 28 core Mac Pro.

PT compatibility Q4 of 2025. :D

Eric Lambert 03-08-2022 11:18 AM

New "Mac Studio" finally enters the world
 
As a 2013-era Trashcan owner, this new Mac is exciting. Small, powerful and with a (believe it or not) *fair* price tag. Shipping soon.

The question for ProTools users is: how soon will we be able to use these? It will undoubtedly ship with Monterey, which is one wrinkle, but it also employs a version of the M1 chip, which is, potentially, another issue.

I'm certain we'll see people diving in from Day 1, trying PT and all their plugins. As an owner of a Mac that's quite long in the tooth, I'd love to be one of those people. But I won't be. Not right away. So I'll be watching for those reports.

Still, it's VERY exciting news. Finally filling the gap between the Mini and the desktop MacPros, which are insanely priced.

What're your thoughts about this new machine?

junkgear 03-08-2022 11:32 AM

Re: New "Mac Studio" finally enters the world
 
Really nice to see this addition to the Mac lineup. I too always thought the mini was not enough and the Pro was too much. I do wish the entry level Studio had more options than just the two. A model with 32GB RAM and the Ultra processor would be nice.

As far as software, as soon as everyone releases native M1 support, it will work on these too. Will be interesting to see how they do in the wild.

Tweakhead 03-08-2022 11:48 AM

Re: New "Mac Studio" finally enters the world
 
the major issue I see is the TB4 cable length spec of 2m max.
how are people supposed to hook up displays, CPU, and audio interface in anything other than a desktop situation ?
there doesn't even seem to be a 3rd-party solution.
are people with this need of racked audio interface/computer with a remote display/keyboard simply just gonna ignore the TB4 displays and go with HDMI instead ?
it seems to defeat the whole point of getting an integrated Apple CPU/Display system.

Eric Lambert 03-08-2022 11:51 AM

Re: New "Mac Studio" finally enters the world
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by junkgear (Post 2629487)
Really nice to see this addition to the Mac lineup. I too always thought the mini was not enough and the Pro was too much. I do wish the entry level Studio had more options than just the two. A model with 32GB RAM and the Ultra processor would be nice.

As far as software, as soon as everyone releases native M1 support, it will work on these too. Will be interesting to see how they do in the wild.

Agreed, a $2999 option, with in-between specs, would have been nice to see.

I feel like it might take some time for the industry to wean itself completely off of Rosetta, and knowing that non-Native software will stay in our worlds for a bit longer I'm wondering how typical PT sessions will operate from the get-go.

Eric Lambert 03-08-2022 11:54 AM

Re: New "Mac Studio" finally enters the world
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tweakhead (Post 2629488)
the major issue I see is the TB4 cable length spec of 2m max.
how are people supposed to hook up displays, CPU, and audio interface in anything other than a desktop situation ?
there doesn't even seem to be a 3rd-party solution.
are people with this need of racked audio interface/computer with a remote display/keyboard simply just gonna ignore the TB4 displays and go with HDMI instead ?
it seems to defeat the whole point of getting an integrated Apple CPU/Display system.

I guess I didn't catch that. Are you saying that TB4 lengths beyond 2 meters won't work in any capacity? Or that they simply won't work at their maximum specs? I have a 4K monitor, currently using a mini displayport, which in no way requires the maximum bandwidth from its connection, and I never thought I'd be limited to 2 meters.

As far as the location where this Mac is intended to be placed, it seems to be akin to a MacMini in that it's designed to be on or near the monitor -- *not* being called a Pro model -- so perhaps they feel that 2 meters is enough for this application. Though, again, I don't know the details of the 2 meter TB4 limitation(s).

BScout 03-08-2022 12:13 PM

Re: New "Mac Studio" finally enters the world
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tweakhead (Post 2629488)
the major issue I see is the TB4 cable length spec of 2m max.
how are people supposed to hook up displays, CPU, and audio interface in anything other than a desktop situation ?
there doesn't even seem to be a 3rd-party solution.
are people with this need of racked audio interface/computer with a remote display/keyboard simply just gonna ignore the TB4 displays and go with HDMI instead ?
it seems to defeat the whole point of getting an integrated Apple CPU/Display system.

TB4 is backwards compatible.
Long distance TB3 works just fine.

Tweakhead 03-08-2022 12:19 PM

Re: New "Mac Studio" finally enters the world
 
well, I must admit that I'm no expert in this. I'm still in 5,1 Mac Pro land, with a DVI monitor (easily extendable) and USB extension for the keyboard (again, easily extendable).
I've been trying to think thru the logistics of upgrading my entire system, and this TB4 length limitation is something that still keeps me from jumping into an entire new computer/audio interface/display ecosystem. It's simply not designed for the pro world where people have machine rooms/racks/patchbays/workstations.
I was really wanting to go dual displays too. (I've been a "Command"+"=" person for so long that it's faster than glancing at another screen, along with my palette of screen configs)
I'm kinda hoping this thread turns into a serious shared-information tip resource for everyone in the same situation - especially since this Mac Studio machine looks like a reasonable contender for new powerful Pro Tools systems.
Here's one interesting read:
https://plugable.com/blogs/news/what...olt-4-and-usb4

and then this (which confuses me more than ever) :
https://nascompares.com/answer/maxim...-to-extend-it/

are we all gonna need endless active docking stations ?

massivekerry 03-08-2022 01:04 PM

Re: New "Mac Studio" finally enters the world
 
I'm very much looking forward to reports to see how it performs in real-world studio applications. Especially with Pro Tools, obviously... which we'll need a Native, Monterey-supporting version first. 128TB memory is the minimum I could deal with, but maybe Kontakt and Spitfire/OT sample players will become more conservative/efficient with Memory usage under AS?

The big elephant for me will also be if/how I can implement my HD|Native card, in a chasis or otherwise.

Carl Lie 03-08-2022 01:22 PM

Re: New "Mac Studio" finally enters the world
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by massivekerry (Post 2629500)
The big elephant for me will also be if/how I can implement my HD|Native card, in a chassis or otherwise.

Same here.

C


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:19 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited. Forum Hosted By: URLJet.com