Group clip gain adjustment problem

[Ke productions]

Hey folks,
Scenario;
I take three (3) tracks (soprano, alto, and tenor); highlight the three waves; right click and select group. Now I have one big group consisting of three tracks. I use clip gain to increase the group track 3db's. When I release the mouse, the third track in the group (the bottom track) SEPARATES from the other two, leaving me with the first two tracks as a group, and the third one alone by itself, Is this a bug? Or is there some NEW OPTION I don't know about that I need to change?
Im dealing with choir tracks and this thing is DRIVING ME NUTS!!!!
Running PT 11.2.1.

Somebody please help me!
Thanks

[Ke productions]

NOBODY? DIGITECHSUPT?
ANYBODY???

[Ke productions]

Originally Posted by Niner

Unable to replicate this behavior here. My clip-gain adjusted track remains grouped with the other two.
No idea why yours is splitting off, and can't imagine why it would be by design.
Seems more like a bug than a practical 'feature', but for someone else it might be a "useful" behavior, but I don't know how. Good luck.

PT 11.2.2 Native
OS X 10.9.5 (13F34)
MBP 9,1 i7

Thanks Niner,
Do you know if I can put a screenshot or video up so others can see?

[Ke productions]

Here's a video of the problem.
Lemme know what you guys think.
Thanks

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/...bug%20fast.mov

[dougdi]

Same problem here on PT 11 HD 11.2.1, 10.9.4. It wasn't always like this.
Doug Di Franco
difrancopro.com

[Ke productions]

Originally Posted by dougdi

Same problem here on PT 11 HD 11.2.1, 10.9.4. It wasn't always like this.
Doug Di Franco
difrancopro.com

Glad Im not alone.

[joachim]

Originally Posted by Ke productions

NOBODY?

Same on Win 7 and PT 11.2.1 .
But only, when dragging the clip gain fader, not when dragging the clip gain line or when changing clip gain with the mouse scrollwheel or with the up/down arrows.
(Thread might be moved to the PT 11 Forum to gain more "publicity".)

[Rich Breen]

Are you absolutely certain that you haven't accidentally gotten a clip gain change somewhere in that bottom clip? What happens if you separate the clip group, ungroup it, do a "Clear Clip Gain" to the bottom clip, then re-group and try it?

Is this behavior repeatable with any region group, or is it just happening with this one?

best,
rich

[joachim]

Originally Posted by Rich Breen

Are you ...

Me ?

Originally Posted by Rich Breen

... absolutely certain that you haven't accidentally gotten a clip gain change somewhere in that bottom clip? What happens if you separate the clip group, ungroup it, do a "Clear Clip Gain" to the bottom clip, then re-group and try it?
Is this behavior repeatable with any region group, or is it just happening with this one?

Yes, happens on any 3 new tracks with freshly consolidated clips, grouped and clip gain adjusted via the clip gain fader (easy to reproduce).

[Ke productions]

Originally Posted by Rich Breen

Are you absolutely certain that you haven't accidentally gotten a clip gain change somewhere in that bottom clip? What happens if you separate the clip group, ungroup it, do a "Clear Clip Gain" to the bottom clip, then re-group and try it?

Is this behavior repeatable with any region group, or is it just happening with this one?

best,
rich

It is absolutely repeatable every time.
If i hit command Z to undo it, I get a crazy result. The top clips remain affected and the bottom clip is softer BUT THEY RETURN TO A GROUP.
I don't know if you've seen the video but here it is again.

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/...bug%20fast.mov