Video playback Windows 10

[sw rec]

I have to be missing something elemental, I keep telling myself. Ever since PT 2019, (Win 10, build 1909) I have been unable to successfully import video of ANY format into Pro Tools, and where 2020.3 is otherwise working great, I still get the spinning icon of death and have to force-quit when I try to import video.

Avid says:
Supported video formats
DNxHR (MOV)
DNxHD (MOV)
Apple ProRes (MOV)
H.264 (CFR Media Only) (MOV, MP4, M4V)

Should I be able to play these videos OUTSIDE of Pro Tools, and if Windows won’t play them, that’s the underlying problem? Am I missing a Windows app somewhere? I’ve tried importing every one of these, with the “improved” video engine which comes with 2020.3 (you have to manually install it...doesn’t get installed with the main installer.)
I’m glad at this point that I left PT 10.3 in place, because I can still import .mov files without issue, and go to work. It even worked with 12.4, but video playback was very jerky.
Thanks in advance for any light you can shed on this.

[sw rec]

Update. To the point. This new video engine DOES NOT WORK in Windows. Something as simple as trying to resize the (blank) video window crashes the video engine, and sends it into an endless loop trying to reinitialize. Wondering how well Studio One handles video import. But this is my last $399 I shell out for their “support/update plan.”

[AndrewAction]

Originally Posted by sw rec

Am I missing a Windows app somewhere?

Try VLC- Media Player

Andrew

[sw rec]

Does that need to be installed for video to play within Pro Tools? Interesting....I’ll try it.

[Brandonx1]

Originally Posted by sw rec

Does that need to be installed for video to play within Pro Tools? Interesting....I’ll try it.

if you go to the video engine folder in the pro tools app, whats in that folder?

[sw rec]

From the “call me crazy, but at least it works” department. There’s a VST video player plugin (vidplayvst.com) that’s $25. And since I already have Blue Cat Patchwork, I says to myself “self, this is worth a try.” And it WORKS! I haven’t tried a lot of video formats with it yet, but I was able to open up an instrument track in pt 2020.3, insert Patchwork, put the video player on the first “pre” slot, and import a mxf-mpeg video file. (I have a converter that’ll output any file format I need.) One extra step: import audio, select the video you just imported, tell it “new track,” and it aligns the reference audio track to the reference audio on the video. I have a screen-shot, but unfortunately it won’t let me post it here. But I have video in PT 2020.3.
If this is something that has caused you frustration, this is certainly worth a try. Only downside so far...close the Patchwork window, it closes the video window too, and that’s one extra thing on the monitors, but that’s a minor inconvenience from where I sit.

[sw rec]

Update. DNxHD works great, H264 works great, .mov files are good, mxf files give video but no audio reference track. One negative I’ll have to live with is that the video window doesn’t scrub with the audio. Spotting frame-specific effects will be a little trickier, but is doable.

[tom_lowe]

Originally Posted by sw rec

Does that need to be installed for video to play within Pro Tools? Interesting....I’ll try it.

VLC has absolutely nothing to do with the AVE!

[adavies]

I've been fine with guys most recent build. I was using V6 (which is my favorite ffmpeg gui) to make DNxHR LB files and loved it, but this most recent windows update killed it for me. If DaVinci can make them I'll go there now. Thanks for the tip!

Sent from my Pixel 4 XL using Tapatalk