ICON vs S1's bundled together

[jkess]

Can anyone tell me why I'd be better off with an ICON than a few S1's wtih iPads on top bundled together?

[YYR123]

Nope we can’t


Go get them S1’s and get to mixing

[Ryan Young]

Custom Fader Groups and XMon. Tangible EQ and Compression knobs as well as surround panner. Better quality faders (so I hear).

[Rich Breen]

Unless you're freezing your system, icon is already well past its EOL. All feature development from Avid going forward will be for Eucon systems.

[clivvy]

the ICON still better than S1 the only thing a S1 has is a smaller footprint!

[arche3]

I'd argue the icon d control is still ahead of the s6m40 right now. But this won't last as new functions get added to s6.

Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

[Mark Ziebarth]

Originally Posted by arche3

I'd argue the icon d control is still ahead of the s6m40 right now. But this won't last as new functions get added to s6.

Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

I guess it depends on your personal workflow. D Control is more an old school console with dedicated controls for a lot of mixing functions. The modern Avid controllers leave more room for individual setups, mainly with touchscreens and their versatile encoders and knobs at the edges. They support you when editing, in playlist handling, with clip gain and many more.

Best

Mark

[PTPerson]

ICON feels like a console.

S6 feels like a computer controlling a computer. I'm not into it.

Running 2018.4 here and loving life.

[arche3]

Originally Posted by PTPerson

ICON feels like a console.



S6 feels like a computer controlling a computer. I'm not into it.



Running 2018.4 here and loving life.

Agreed. We just ball and make hits. I'm not editing crap.

Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

[mixkidd]

anyone help on this please?? JUST POSTING AS RECENT COMMS HERE

Hi There

hopefully someone can shed light on this really odd problem eg a ICON Pro
I'm Using PT10.3 HD with no issues doing mix recalls. THE PICS SHOW SAME MIX PLAYING VIA MAIN AND THENAT SAME TIME THE STEREO RETURNS (VIA 192 AES/OPTICAL)

I could really do with thoughts on how people wired analogue inputs of stereo mastering machines from xmon, or is this dependent on solely mapping I/o?
icon stereo 1/2/3 outputs output returns are working fine via 192 optical signals. but please read the issue below.

When monitoring any mix on headphones or Main/Alt/Mini monitors - I hear full stereo/mono albeit on ICON as LCR 5.1 output...so Left =ch1 right =ch5 (see i/o pic)
Ii then monitor the same mix via optical/AES/Spdif digital outputs via the on board stereo returns 1/2/3 AND THEY ALL play on left side only despite mix still playing full stereo on meter ch1/ch2 when on main output monitor playback. (see pic)

So I decided to change the mix outputs to ch 1and 2 and this time the stereo mix plays on meters ch1/ch2 but only left side/no right channel on headphones or monitors and any optical mix/digital mix is back to stereo in headphones and monitors (see i/o pic)

my question is how to get both main mix or optical 2 track returns to playback on the same meters (eg either ch1/ch5 OR ch1/ch2 NOT BOTH AT SAME TIME) and always be stereo in headphones and monitors.
I need to mix and be able switch from stereo to stereo returns and not lose the right channel. the console has this facility on it monitor section.
I even tried to match 2 x stereo outputs on i/o and it totally wiped the metering all over the place.t...Trial and error is just not working.

Seems like a mad problem that has stuffed me to sort out.
the desk and all outputs are all ok and the digidesign imo manuals barely touches on the full wiring output capacity of this console - so not much use.

if anyone has a .pio i/o set up file to send over that might solve this ...then please do ...as this issue is wasting a lot of time to sort. before anyone asks i have fully reset the I/O and then recalled it back on several occasions ..nothing seems to solve this multi monitoring issue so far.
I can mix but it s a really annoying restriction. all stereo tests here are perfect but this digital default to monitor/playback on meters l=ch1 and r=ch2 is mad as the d command works on 5.1 and stereo.
so any mix is generally outputting...left = ch1 and right = ch5.
I have tried to reset to stereo only but no joy

Thank you very much in advance - stay safe.