Hardware Control Surface Recommendation

[ramonetl]

Hi all, I spent many hours last night googling, reading reviews, threads, forums you name it trying to make a decision about getting a control surface. Some back story first though: I used a pair if echo audio firewire 12s with a TAC Scorpion. Once that unit burned up I started in a new direction. Initially I replaced the Console with a A&H QU-32 which was really cool and allowed me to sell the 2 FW units and go pretty much direct. However I was unable to fully bypass the pres etc and I ultimately discovered and invested in an Apollo 8p. Over time I picked up a Twin quad and I also have a quad Satellite so I have a decent amount of DSP power. I also bought a year ago a 6core Mac Pro which I upgraded ram to 64GB and the SSD to 1TB and have been super stable (no more crashes) and very happy with. I ultimately sold the QU-32 to pay for the apollo stuff since I didnt really need it anymore.

So with the evolution of my studio I have been extremely happy but I am missing a few things such as the ability to use a foot switch bc when I am tracking my instruments this is a PITA to time sometimes and being in the other room is out. I also found I miss the feel of faders and mixing multiple tracks at the same time without really staring at the screen constantly.

So enter the Control apps and the new ProTools Dock. It looks like it fills a nice niche and the S3 looks bomb. I dont need Preamps or monitor outs etc so i am not looking for a unit that has all this. I also have limited space in my desk so the form factor looks really ideal. But this is where I get into a dilemma and that is between the S3 which looks and seems amazing but it super expensive or getting a dock and then do the artist mix still connect to it physically as they did the older unit. I found a couple of pictures where it appears so and I wonder am I better off just getting a couple of used mixes and maybe later down the road switch to a S3, just figure out a way to get a used S3 (I do see a few) which financially presents a dilemma at the moment or just get a dock and leave it at that for now? Sorry if I am not clear what I want but I am trying to make some decision and i feel like the googling has painted my brain into a corner. My gut says get a Dock and a couple of used Mix units and maybe down the road sell em if I get my hands on a S3. That they added VCA spill as an option seems to address on big complaint. Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Thanks. Peter

Oh I almost forgot! When you join the artist mix do they share a single power source? I never found an answer to that but a plug running from each would be messy.

Omnirax Omnidesk
Uad Apollo 8p quad
Uad Satellite
Uad Twin quad
JoeMeek Twin Q
Miktek MPA-201
Kemper Profiler Rack
Two Notes Torpedo Live
Mac Pro 6,1 64GB 6Core 1TB SSD
High Sierra running latest PT