Avid Pro Audio Community

Avid Pro Audio Community (https://duc.avid.com/index.php)
-   Artist Series (https://duc.avid.com/forumdisplay.php?f=62)
-   -   Need work-around: "EuCon will not function well after sleep" (https://duc.avid.com/showthread.php?t=305640)

jasperhb 08-10-2011 06:50 AM

Need work-around: "EuCon will not function well after sleep"
 
It is stated in the FAQ that EuCon will not function well after sleep. http://euphonix.avid.com/artist/ux/e...s.php?detail=5

However, it must be possible to work around this some how?!

If I log out of Windows 7 and back in, EuCon connects beautifully after sleep mode, which leads me to think that all I really need is a means to stop and start a service in the computer after sleep - i.e. intiate the connection process again. Logging in and out is possible, but a rather slow workaround given that this forces the PC to reinitiate the whole desktop, all users services etc. etc. It takes approx. 2-3 minutes, when this should really take only a couple of seconds.

Could someone please point me in the right direction?

BTW: This explaintion makes no sense to me: "Sleep loses the network connection on the workstation, and EuCon goes into a bad state because it needs an active network to be available. Our EuCon database process that runs in the background will no longer receive messages from the existing EuCon nodes (application and/or workstations on the network) and will therefore remove the nodes. They will have to be relaunched after this to become available again.

Well, I fully understands what it says, however considering that a whole computer with multiple USB's etc. etc., network connection etc. etc. is capable of going in and out off sleep easily, then this seems somewhat of an excuse. Of course it is possible to evolve the EuCon protocol to manage sleep... or at least add some "reconnect button" to the EuControl...

The MC transport is a cool, elegant and beautify product. To this moment this sleep issue is the only thing that disappoints me. And, frankly given the attention to details and the pricetag of this product I'm abit surprised (and disappointed). Luckily this should be easy to fixed with a minor software update ;-)

Xill 08-10-2011 06:55 AM

Re: Need work-around: "EuCon will not function well after sleep"
 
I think this is a system issue.
It does the same thing on Mac Os x.

When the computer goes to sleep it shuts down the ethernet connections.
I agree that Eucon shouldn't crash and should manage to somehow stay connected to the sequencer, but it may be harder to do than it seems.

I had to set up my computer to never sleep during the day and I have to close Logic, and Eucon related programs at night.

On my Mac I have made an automator file that quits and reload all programs automatically (reassigning all the channels properly).

jasperhb 08-10-2011 10:41 AM

Re: Need work-around: "EuCon will not function well after sleep"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xill (Post 1823572)
I think this is a system issue.
It does the same thing on Mac Os x.

When the computer goes to sleep it shuts down the ethernet connections.
I agree that Eucon shouldn't crash and should manage to somehow stay connected to the sequencer, but it may be harder to do than it seems.

I had to set up my computer to never sleep during the day and I have to close Logic, and Eucon related programs at night.

On my Mac I have made an automator file that quits and reload all programs automatically (reassigning all the channels properly).

Thanks Xill. I agree that the devil is often to be found in the details, but at least some "reconnect" button in the software should be possible for a quick manual process.

If not, then I hope that someone could tell me what services or processes I might kill and restart myself? :-)

Bill Denton 08-10-2011 05:03 PM

Re: Need work-around: "EuCon will not function well after sleep"
 
When the computer goes to sleep it shuts down the ethernet connections.
I agree that Eucon shouldn't crash and should manage to somehow stay connected to the sequencer, but it may be harder to do than it seems.


C'mon, guys...THINK!

Xill 08-10-2011 06:42 PM

Re: Need work-around: "EuCon will not function well after sleep"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Denton (Post 1823747)
When the computer goes to sleep it shuts down the ethernet connections.
I agree that Eucon shouldn't crash and should manage to somehow stay connected to the sequencer, but it may be harder to do than it seems.


C'mon, guys...THINK!

Obviously you have the solution.

jasperhb 08-10-2011 11:28 PM

Re: Need work-around: "EuCon will not function well after sleep"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Denton (Post 1823747)
When the computer goes to sleep it shuts down the ethernet connections.
I agree that Eucon shouldn't crash and should manage to somehow stay connected to the sequencer, but it may be harder to do than it seems.


C'mon, guys...THINK!

And your point is???

Bill Denton 08-11-2011 03:41 AM

Re: Need work-around: "EuCon will not function well after sleep"
 
The solution? Sure...just do it the same way you do it to keep your TV on after you unplug the power cord.

The point is...This situation is very thoroughly explained in the FAQ. If the ethernet on the computer is shut down, there is no way for the Eucon device to communicate with it.

The Eucon device needs to communicate with the computer in order to maintain "state".

End of story...

Xill 08-11-2011 05:07 AM

Re: Need work-around: "EuCon will not function well after sleep"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Denton (Post 1823884)
The solution? Sure...just do it the same way you do it to keep your TV on after you unplug the power cord.

The point is...This situation is very thoroughly explained in the FAQ. If the ethernet on the computer is shut down, there is no way for the Eucon device to communicate with it.

The Eucon device needs to communicate with the computer in order to maintain "state".

End of story...

We're not saying that it's a problem that it disconnects, but that it crashes.
If it didn't crash then a connection could be re-established.

I wouldn't be so sure that it's impossible to fix with an simultaneous update on the sequencers and Eucon side.

jasperhb 08-11-2011 08:42 AM

Re: Need work-around: "EuCon will not function well after sleep"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Denton (Post 1823884)
The solution? Sure...just do it the same way you do it to keep your TV on after you unplug the power cord.

The point is...This situation is very thoroughly explained in the FAQ. If the ethernet on the computer is shut down, there is no way for the Eucon device to communicate with it.

The Eucon device needs to communicate with the computer in order to maintain "state".

End of story...

Bill. Do you work for AVID? Or, do you have some other insights into this matter meaning that your are in a position to rule out that a software update could indeed fix this issue or provide some sort of easy and managable work-around, such as for exampel a "reinitiate/reconnect" button in the EuControl software?

Bill Denton 08-11-2011 05:00 PM

Re: Need work-around: "EuCon will not function well after sleep"
 
Okay...I was a bit harsh and I sincerely apologize...

No, I don't work for Avid but I have been an IT guy for 22 years...mostly software, but way more hardware than I ever wanted to deal with.

I imagine it might be possible to do a software "fix", but it would not be easy to do. Once the Ethernet is disconnected, both the computer and the Eucon unit are subject to change in state. And compensating for that would make things really complicated.

Now, while it could technically be done, would Avid be willing to do it. And my best guess is, given that they recommend disabling "sleep' on machines running Pro Tools, they probably would not be that interested in fixing it.

Both the Pro Tools and the Eucon programmers have a lot of "serious" problems on their plates, and I doubt that what would basically be a "convenience" issue affecting only a small number of users would even make it onto their "to do" list.

Avid may surprise us all, but I wouldn't hold my breath...


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 11:54 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited. Forum Hosted By: URLJet.com