Avid Pro Audio Community

Avid Pro Audio Community (https://duc.avid.com/index.php)
-   Artist Series (https://duc.avid.com/forumdisplay.php?f=62)
-   -   Updated firmware for MC Mix & EUCON networking fix - When? (https://duc.avid.com/showthread.php?t=362962)

O-WYO 01-10-2015 09:20 PM

Updated firmware for MC Mix & EUCON networking fix - When?
 
Come on, Avid. It's been way too long since the last MC Mix firmware "upgrade" disabled the "Shift + fader sets level to 0dB" feature. And we've all been crippling along, ever since. That is (was) one of my favorite and often used features of the MC Mix.

When can we expect an updated firmware for the MC Mix?

While you're at it, how about updating EUCON to work properly in modern (ie beyond basic) networks - like v3.1.3 does?

Having spent thousands on my MC Control and MC Mixes, it's distressing to see firmware and driver "updates" actually regress the functionality of the Artist Series. I'm on the verge of upgrading my entire DAW and AD/DA I/O setup. For sure, this ongoing Artist Series debacle is killing any warm and fuzzy inclination to go with to Avid Protools & hardware!

*** Addendum, 1/13/2015: Per post #13 on this thread, the disabled "Shift+Touch Fader=0dB" bug is apparently not a problem with MC Mix firmware. As stated by several forum posters in various threads, it appears to be a problem with EUCON/EuControl.

I just downgraded EUCON/EuControl to v3.0.1, while leaving the MC Mix firmware at v1.5.2. Lo and behold, the "S+TF=0dB" feature has been restored. In addition, EUCON appears to be communicating properly with my network and my MC controllers. Time will tell how well v3.0.1 works with OS X 10.9.5 and Cubase 7.5.30; but, so far, so good.

Barlow 01-10-2015 10:33 PM

Re: Updated firmware for MC Mix & EUCON networking fix - When?
 
Option + Touch Fader = 0db. On a Mac anyway. Or Option + Click on Fader.

O-WYO 01-11-2015 04:32 PM

Re: Updated firmware for MC Mix & EUCON networking fix - When?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barlow (Post 2220206)
Option + Touch Fader = 0db. On a Mac anyway. Or Option + Click on Fader.

Yeah, that's what I've been relegated to using ever since the firmware "update". While that resets the fader in the DAW, it does not reset the fader on the Mix. I didn't buy a bunch of MC Mix's, to then have to use the mouse to control my faders!

O-WYO 01-11-2015 04:41 PM

Re: Updated firmware for MC Mix & EUCON networking fix - When?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kdarbyshirebryant (Post 2220238)
The breakage of 'shift+touch fader = 0dB' feature on the Artist Mix (but not control) was as a result of fixing this http://protools.ideascale.com/a/dtd/...ks/113320-3779

From what I remember it's a EUCON problem rather than induced by firmware.

I don't believe it's a EUCON problem. My Mix units worked just fine, right up to the point I updated the firmware.

The EUCON problem I'm encountering is the inability of v3.2.x to evidently work with link aggregation and/or VLAN's. Inexplicably, v3.1.3 works just fine. It's a matter of properly interfacing EUCON with the host computer TCP/IP stack.

Bill Denton 01-11-2015 08:14 PM

Re: Updated firmware for MC Mix & EUCON networking fix - When?
 
In order to get consistently good performance, you really should have your Eucon units on a separate physical network.

It appears that problems often result from having a mix of Eucon and non-Eucon traffic on the same physical network.

To facilitate having Eucon units on a separate network, Avid has a built-in DHCP server on their S6 system, and the manual strongly recommends the use of a separate network.

Using a separate network is a cheap "fix", it will in no way degrade performance, and it completely eliminates one possible source of problems.

robertg 01-12-2015 01:00 AM

Re: Updated firmware for MC Mix & EUCON networking fix - When?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Denton (Post 2220486)
In order to get consistently good performance, you really should have your Eucon units on a separate physical network.

This is not necessary.

Bill Denton 01-12-2015 05:00 AM

Re: Updated firmware for MC Mix & EUCON networking fix - When?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kdarbyshirebryant (Post 2220531)
I just tested this by loading v1.5.1 firmware on my mix unit - the 'shift - touch fader = 0dB' functionality is still broken in the sense that Pro Tools sees the control value change (ie the virtual fader moves) but unfortunately the real fader doesn't. The problem was introduced by a EUCon application update and not the firmware update.

Actually the behaviour is stranger than that. On the MC Control 'shift touch =0dB' works correctly all the time. On the Mix, the first time I load a session & touch a fader it works, if I undo the fader move and try 'shift touch' the PT fader moves but the real one doesn't. If I have the same channel mapped to an MC Control fader then the MC version of the fader moves correctly whilst the Mix fader doesn't.

Almost sounds like a hardware issue...

Do you have two mixes so you could see if the behavior is isolated to only one unit or if it might be consistent across multiple mixs?

A firmware issue might also be in play.

Good job on picking up on that...

O-WYO 01-13-2015 12:04 PM

Re: Updated firmware for MC Mix & EUCON networking fix - When?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Denton (Post 2220486)
In order to get consistently good performance, you really should have your Eucon units on a separate physical network.

It certainly makes sense to run EUCON on its own network; although, I don't see why it wouldn't function on a common network (assuming sufficient bandwidth and decent networking equipment).

My network is run on a 24-port, layer 2 switch. The switch runs several VLAN's, including the primary default VLAN and a dedicated EUCON VLAN. The default and EUCON VLAN's are on a different subnets.

The MC units connect to ports that are tagged to the EUCON VLAN. The MC units have static IP's on the EUCON subnet.

My MacPro's two NIC's are link aggregated and connect to switch ports that are untagged. The LAGG interface is configured to run on the switch's default VLAN. An additional virtual interface is configured for the EUCON VLAN. Outbound traffic through the EUCON VLAN is therefore tagged for the EUCON VLAN, before it reaches the switch. Thus, EUCON is essentially run on its own network.

While not exactly a common home network setup, the above is pretty basic for business environments - especially in commercial audio/visual production facilities.

The problem is v3.2.x lost its ability to recognize and connect with the network interfaces that are configured on my Mac. There is no connection problem with v3.1.3; although, EUCON does not properly identify the LAGG interface by name nor does it list the EUCON VLAN.

The bottom line is programming EUCON to properly function within the parameters of established TCP/IP protocols should not be a problem.

O-WYO 01-13-2015 12:32 PM

Re: Updated firmware for MC Mix & EUCON networking fix - When?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kdarbyshirebryant (Post 2220531)
I just tested this by loading v1.5.1 firmware on my mix unit - the 'shift - touch fader = 0dB' functionality is still broken in the sense that Pro Tools sees the control value change (ie the virtual fader moves) but unfortunately the real fader doesn't. The problem was introduced by a EUCon application update and not the firmware update.

Actually the behaviour is stranger than that. On the MC Control 'shift touch =0dB' works correctly all the time. On the Mix, the first time I load a session & touch a fader it works, if I undo the fader move and try 'shift touch' the PT fader moves but the real one doesn't. If I have the same channel mapped to an MC Control fader then the MC version of the fader moves correctly whilst the Mix fader doesn't.

Interesting! How did you downgrade the firmware to v1.5.1? EuControl only gives me the option to update the firmware.

I can't find a firmware revision list on the Avid website; however, it could be that v1.5.1 also disables the "shift+touch fader=0dB" feature. If that's the case, downgrading to v1.5.1 wouldn't solve the problem.

As far as it being a firmware, EUCON, and/or EuControl problem, it could well be a combination of two or all three. All I know is the feature worked fine until I updated the firmware.

BTW, I tried to duplicate your experience, loading a new session, then using "shift+touch fader=0dB". It didn't work for me. I'm on Cubase 7.5.30, though.

O-WYO 01-13-2015 01:08 PM

Re: Updated firmware for MC Mix & EUCON networking fix - When?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kdarbyshirebryant (Post 2220572)
To add to my previous reply - the 'shift + touch fader =0dB' feature not working on Artist Mix has been around quite some time and was introduced in EUCon 3.1 and is a side effect of fixing this http://www.protools.ideascale.com/a/...ks/113320-3779 which was documented in this http://duc.avid.com/showthread.php?t=346347

Discussion of the 'shift + touch =0dB' breaking is found here http://duc.avid.com/showthread.php?t=348646 itself now a year old. The breakage doesn't affect MC Control units because..... they don't have a flip mode. I could have sworn that there was an ideascale entry for the 'shift + touch = 0dB' thing not working but I can't find it. Oh well.

Meanwhile, ever since the release of PT 11 (!) there are persistent little irritants related to incorrect modifier key usage in the default soft key maps on Windows which still aren't fixed despite it being a very easy thing to do. See http://protools.ideascale.com/a/dtd/...gs/121345-3779 for example. And if you want the fix take a look at the attachment on that entry.

To not include these fixes which a customer has provided is shoddy, simple as. It's another thing that puts me off saying to others 'come on in, the water's lovely'.

Brilliant, my good man! Thanks for providing the link http://duc.avid.com/showthread.php?t=348646! I read that thread, quite some time ago, but had forgotten it's contents. (In hindsight, I should've subscribed for future reference.)

The crunchy nut in that thread is post #10; which was, in fact, posted by you! Following your lead, I installed EUCON v3.0.1, left the MC Mix firmware at v1.5.2, and, lo and behold, not only does EUCON properly connect to my network, the "Shift+Touch Fader=0dB" feature is back on my MC Mix controllers!

So, I stand corrected. The "S+TF=0dB" problem is apparently not a firmware problem, but a problem with EUCON/EuControl.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 06:52 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited. Forum Hosted By: URLJet.com