Midi Piano Notes Randomly Not Sustaining
 

I have a MIDI piano track that is displaying an annoying anomaly where it will suddenly decide it's not going to allow notes to sustain. On one pass, all will be fine. Stop and start again and the notes are all staccato. I've played with various cache and buffer settings, but nothing seems to have any effect. I'm running 32gb of RAM, no other programs open, the environment dedicated to PT. I've attached a shot of my System Usage to show where things are at the moment.

Would like to get this worked out so I can stay on task.

Thanks.

Re: Midi Piano Notes Randomly Not Sustaining
 

Do you have a MIDI keyboard connected? I started a thread here were I outlined the problems I was having with my Motif 7 keyboard apparently sending out spurious things like volume changes and notes cutting off.

Reading your equipment list I'm sure you know this but that Fusion drive in your Mac isn't helping things any. They've been known to cause all sorts of issues. That may or may not be the cause here - just saying.

Re: Midi Piano Notes Randomly Not Sustaining
 

Check in the manual for chasing controllers and breakpoints.

Re: Midi Piano Notes Randomly Not Sustaining
 

Hey, Jack/musicman691;

I tried doing a Quick Reply to your post, but apparently the "Please click one of the Quick Reply icons in the posts above to activate Quick Reply" suggestion is another of those endless things designed to aggravate the hell out of us, since there doesn't seem to be any such thing as a "Quick Reply Icon" in any of the posts.

A year or so ago, while updating to Mohave, the hybrid drive you referred to had to be replaced because Mohave didn't support it. I believe what I have now is a single SSD, based on the attached report image. But this does bring up a question: I've heard PT performs better when files are on an external drive. Is that the case, and—if so—why would that be?

I'd like to follow you "Motif 7" thread but can't find it. Could you send a link to that?

Thanks

Re: Midi Piano Notes Randomly Not Sustaining
 

Chuck S;

Searching the reference guide and Avid knowledge base, nothing comes up for "chasing controllers and breakpoints".

Re: Midi Piano Notes Randomly Not Sustaining
 

First things first:
Yeah it's very confusing with the 'quick reply' business. I'd been on here for years and never understood until one day I asked someone where it came up in a thread and they explained it. When you go to the last post on a page on the lower left there's a 'post reply' button. Click on that and that allows one to use the 'quick reply' window. It's really misnamed to tell the truth. So don't feel bad about it.

Second:
Hard to tell from your screen shot as I don't think you show everything. Here's a link on how to tell if you have a regular Fusion drive and whether it's been split: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207584

Lastly:
Here's a link to the Motif 7 thread (it's called 'debugging can drive one batty'): http://duc.avid.com/showthread.php?t=408947

Re: Midi Piano Notes Randomly Not Sustaining
 

Page 777 of the most recent manual under the heading: Default Controller Values and Chasing
It's in the chapter on MIDI Editing if you have a different manual version.

Re: Midi Piano Notes Randomly Not Sustaining
 

I've seen this with Sonivox plugins, if this is a similar case the only workaround is to turn off loop playback and loop record.

Re: Midi Piano Notes Randomly Not Sustaining
 

Midi Merge is your most probable problem

Re: Midi Piano Notes Randomly Not Sustaining
 

Lots of stuff here:

ChuckS: Thanks. I'll make sure I have the latest manual and check that out.

JFreak: Good suspect, but in my case Midi Merge is off. Thanks, though.

amagras: A likely suspect... loop play/record are on most of the time in my situation. I'm hoping it's something else, though. Having to manually loop playback is going to be a PIA.

Jack/musicman691: You're right: I do have a fusion drive, after checking it out based on the link you gave. That might be the culprit on multiple issues, then. The external drive setup just seems like a violation of the rule of "shortest distance between two points," but I'll give it a shot here. Would an SSD be better than a physical disk drive, or should I just swap out my internal 2TB Fusion for a 2TB SSD?